California's attorney general subpoenas Nvidia over China chips and investor disclosures
The subpoena follows what the attorney general's office called news of former CEO Jensen Huang's affair with an alleged Chinese spy, an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore company under U.S. investigation.
By Marcus Rodriguez ·
Why it matters: The state probe adds to a proposed class action that already accuses Nvidia and Huang of misleading investors about Megaspeed; those claims are allegations.
For information only, not investment advice. Prices delayed.
Tickers: NVDA
The attorney general's office said the information will help it evaluate whether Nvidia ($NVDA) violated California law; the release describes the questions, not the documents the subpoena demands.1 Rob Bonta wants to know whether advanced chips or confidential information reached China, and whether the company misled investors about that risk.1 He served the investigative subpoena on Nov. 19, in connection with the news of former CEO Jensen Huang's affair with an alleged Chinese spy.1
“The conduct of Nvidia and its former CEO raises bright red flags, including about the ways in which the company may have misled investors,” Bonta said.1 He framed the probe around the state's corporate securities law: “Companies cannot mislead their investors.”1
CNBC reported that Bonta's office said the probe concerns whether Nvidia's advanced chips ended up in China in contravention of U.S. export restrictions.2 Alice Huang, who is not related to Jensen Huang, was an executive at Megaspeed, a Singapore-based company being investigated for potentially diverting restricted Nvidia chips to China.2 Megaspeed has said reports about its business contain assertions “not supported by verifiable evidence”.3
The investor question is not new. Nvidia stopped reporting Singapore revenue separately just as scrutiny of Megaspeed was arising, the Los Angeles Times noted.4 A proposed class action filed Nov. 9, TechCrunch reported, accuses Nvidia and Huang of misleading investors about Huang's ties to Megaspeed.5 The suit points to the company's claim that it found “no evidence of diversion” of its chips and Huang's Oct. 30 description of the Megaspeed dealings as “normal and not unusual.”5 Those are the plaintiffs' allegations, not findings.
Washington is looking too. The Commerce Department acknowledged on Monday a years-long investigation into Megaspeed over allegations it may have skirted export rules for Nvidia's AI chips.4 Democrats on the House Judiciary and Foreign Affairs committees are examining whether Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick, whose family has holdings in Nvidia, improperly influenced the administration's response to Nvidia's chip business.4
Nvidia did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the subpoena.2 Its board chair, Harvey Jones, said this week that the company has no intention of reinstating Huang.3 Chief financial officer Colette Kress is serving as interim CEO.4
Sources
- Attorney General Bonta Serves Investigative Subpoena on Nvidia, California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General
- California attorney general issues Nvidia subpoena in probe of China chip diversion, CNBC
- California targets Nvidia in China AI chip probe, BBC News
- California subpoenas Nvidia as questions about CEO affair, AI chips mount, Los Angeles Times
- The race is on to sue Nvidia, TechCrunch
Tags: regulation · semiconductors · china · ai · big-tech