Sainteur · Highly Regarded Market News

Startups

Fourth Circuit refuses to block Maryland from enforcing sports-wagering laws against Kalshi

The November 17 opinion affirms a judge's denial of a preliminary injunction, with the two judges in the majority divided on the reason.

By ·

Why it matters: Kalshi did not get a court order blocking Maryland from enforcing its sports-wagering laws, even as the judges who formed the majority disagreed about why.

For information only, not investment advice.

A published November 17 opinion in KalshiEX LLC v. Martin affirmed a Maryland federal judge's August 1, 2025, denial of a preliminary injunction.1 Kalshi had asked the courts to bar the state from enforcing its sports-wagering laws against the company's sports event contracts.1

On April 7, 2025, Maryland gaming authorities sent Kalshi a cease-and-desist letter asserting the company was unlawfully offering "wagering on sporting events" without a state license and ordering it to stop within 15 days.1 KalshiEX LLC sued the Maryland Attorney General and lottery and gaming officials on April 21, arguing the Commodity Exchange Act preempts those state laws, and sought the injunction.1

Judge Gregory, concurring, wrote that he did not decide whether the contracts are "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act and that, even assuming they are, the law does not clearly establish that they may trade free from state gaming laws.1 He declined to infer preemption, saying Congress has not displaced traditional state police powers over gambling with the clarity required.1

Judge Thacker concurred in the judgment on different grounds, writing that the contracts are not swaps and that Maryland officials can co-regulate them.1 She wrote, "That is gambling, plain and simple."1

Judge Benjamin dissented, writing that the contracts are swaps, that Congress has granted exclusive jurisdiction over such swaps to the CFTC, and that she would vacate the denial of the preliminary injunction and remand for further proceedings.1

Sources

  1. KalshiEX LLC v. Martin, published per curiam opinion, decided November 17, 2026, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit

Tags: regulation · fintech

Earlier on this

More on regulation and fintech